Right to Appraisal for Repair Estimate Disputes
When an insurance company’s repair estimate falls short of what your vehicle actually needs, you have options. The Right to Appraisal provision in most auto insurance policies allows policyholders to challenge inadequate estimates and pursue fair compensation for proper, safe, manufacturer-recommended repairs. This service is designed specifically for vehicle owners who are facing incomplete, underpaid, or improperly assessed repair estimates
Price: $475
Your Designated Appraiser for Repair Cost Disputes
RJ Sweeney, founder of Wreck Check Atlanta, brings over 29 years of collision repair industry experience to every appraisal. As an I-CAR Platinum Level 3 Estimator and ASE-certified collision repair professional, he understands exactly what proper repairs require—from labor rates and procedures to OEM specifications and parts requirements. His methodologies have met the Daubert standard for scientific and legal reliability in Georgia courts, providing the credibility needed when disputing insurance estimates.
“Insurance companies have their own appraisers looking out for their interests,” says RJ Sweeney. “Vehicle owners deserve someone equally qualified advocating for repairs that meet manufacturer standards—not shortcuts that compromise safety or quality.”
Understanding the Right to Appraisal Process
The Right to Appraisal (also called the Appraisal Clause) is a standard provision in most auto insurance policies that provides a formal mechanism for resolving disputes over repair costs. When you and your insurance company cannot agree on the amount of a loss, this clause allows each party to select their own appraiser to assess the claim independently. If the two appraisers cannot reach an agreement, a neutral umpire may be selected to make a binding decision.
As your designated appraiser, Wreck Check Atlanta works to identify discrepancies between the insurance estimate and the actual cost of proper repairs. This includes reviewing labor rates, repair procedures, parts specifications, and OEM requirements to build a supportable case for the correct repair amount.
When to Consider Repair Estimate Appraisal Services
This service addresses situations where an insurance company’s estimate does not fully cover safe, proper repairs. Common scenarios include:
- Insufficient Labor Rates: The estimate uses labor rates below what qualified technicians in your area actually charge
- Missing Repair Operations: Required procedures have been excluded or overlooked, leaving necessary work unfunded
- Aftermarket Parts Substitution: The insurer specifies non-OEM parts when manufacturer parts are needed for proper fit and function
- Ignored OEM Procedures: Manufacturer-required repair steps have been omitted from the estimate
- Underpaid Repair Costs: The total estimate simply does not cover the actual cost of restoring your vehicle correctly
What to Expect from This Service
Once retained as your appraiser, Wreck Check Atlanta conducts a thorough review of your insurance company’s estimate against proper repair standards. This includes identifying missing, underpaid, or improperly excluded repair operations and documenting the correct procedures, parts, and labor required. The findings are then presented directly to the insurance company’s independent appraiser through the formal appraisal process. The goal is to establish the correct, supportable cost of repairs—not rushed compromises or shortcuts.
If the appraisers cannot reach agreement, an independent umpire may be required to render a binding decision. Umpire services, if needed, typically cost an additional $200 to $350 depending on the umpire selected.
Diminished Value Add-On
Beyond repair costs, most vehicles lose market value after an accident—even when repairs are completed properly. If you wish to pursue a diminished value claim alongside your repair estimate dispute, this can be added for an additional $275. This combined approach ensures that both the repair costs and the loss in vehicle value are addressed through one coordinated process.
Frequently Asked Questions About Right to Appraisal Services
Most standard auto insurance policies include an appraisal clause in the "Damage to Your Auto" section. Review your policy documents or contact Wreck Check Atlanta for guidance on locating and invoking this provision.
You will need to provide the insurance company's repair estimate, photos of the damage (or repaired areas if repairs have begun), and any correspondence with the insurer regarding the estimate dispute.
Timeframes vary depending on the complexity of the dispute and the responsiveness of the insurance company's appraiser. Most cases resolve within a few weeks, though umpire involvement may extend this timeline.
Yes. If you paid out of pocket for proper repairs that exceeded the insurance estimate, or if repair quality was compromised due to an inadequate estimate, the appraisal process can still be pursued.
If a mutual agreement cannot be reached, an independent umpire is selected to review both appraisals and render a binding decision. Umpire fees range from $200 to $350 depending on the professional selected.
The Right to Appraisal provision typically applies to first-party claims through your own insurance policy. For disputes involving another driver's insurance, different approaches may be required. Contact Wreck Check Atlanta to discuss your specific situation.
Why Choose Wreck Check Atlanta
Wreck Check Atlanta has built a reputation as the leader in post-collision consumer advocacy throughout Georgia, North Carolina, and South Carolina. When disputing repair estimates, clients benefit from:
- Court-Qualified Expertise: RJ Sweeney’s methodologies have met the Daubert standard for scientific and legal reliability
- Industry Credentials: I-CAR Platinum Level 3 certification, ASE certification, and licensed dealer status across three states
- Comprehensive Documentation: Detailed reports designed to withstand insurance company scrutiny and support your claim
- Proven Track Record: Over 29 years of collision industry experience helping consumers recover fair compensation
Get Started with Your Repair Estimate Dispute in Alpharetta
If your insurance company’s repair estimate does not cover proper, safe repairs for your vehicle, Wreck Check Atlanta is ready to advocate on your behalf. Contact our Alpharetta office at (770) 675-1828 or complete the online intake form to begin the Right to Appraisal process. The team at Wreck Check Atlanta is committed to ensuring your vehicle receives the repairs it needs—not the repairs an insurance adjuster says you can afford.
